and our Sir Arthur Conan Doyle himself would select the very best (that is, his own favorite) Holmes stories, and whichever fan guessed the author's list "most nearly" would win 100 and an autographed copy of Conan Doyle's Memories and Adventures . Sir Arthur Conan Doyle himself would select the very best (that is, his own favorite) Holmes stories, and whichever fan guessed the authors list most nearly would win100 and an autographed copy of Conan DoylesMemories and Adventures. The renowned detective Sherlock Holmes is perhaps the most frequently portrayed literary character in film and TV. Privacy Policy. Henry Lloyd-Hughes takes on the role of Holmes in this series with a completely new look and feel to the character. But not everything Watson wrote was strictly true. I hesitate between Silver Blaze, The Bruce-Partington Plans, The Crooked Man, The Man With the Twisted Lip, The Gloria Scott, The Greek Interpreter, The Reigate Squires, The Musgrave Ritual and The Resident Patient. On what principle am I to choose two out of those? Henry Lloyd-Hughes as Sherlock Holmes in Netflix's The Irregulars. It is also a memory from Holmess early life. 5. A weekly newsletter focusing on literature by and about people of color! Here are the 15 Most Iconic Adaptations of Sherlock Holmes, Ranked Worst To Best. A Study in Charlotte (Charlotte Holmes, #1) by. The adventures of Doyle's iconic detective proved a craze from . In June of 1927, the Editor (presumably) opened the envelope. In March of 1927, just before the final volume of Sherlock Holmes stories,The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes, was due to be published in book form,the Strandintroduced a competition for its readers. In at least three storiesCharles Augustus Milverton,The Three Students, and The Second Stainhe specifically says he left out key details to protect the innocents involved. This is a very highly regarded series, in large part for its faithfulness to the original stories. The Illustrious Client, on the other hand, is not remarkable for plot, but it has a certain dramatic quality and moves adequately in lofty circles, so I should also have found a place for it. The audio I found includes an intro from radio actress Peggy Webber, who says she worked with Rathbone several times, so Im making an educated guess that its her. Therefore we will put it down for the eighth place. This puts The Final Problem, A Scandal in Bohemia, and The Empty House upon our list, and we have got our first half-dozen. On the whole Holmes himself shows perhaps most ingenuity in The Regiate Squires, and therefore this shall be twelfth man in my team. 10. On other occasions, Watson talks about having to wait several years before he could publish a story, and cherry-picking which cases to write about based on whether or not they make Holmes look good. Next to that in popular favor and in my own esteem I would place The Red-Headed League and The Dancing Men, on account in each case of the originality of the plot. As Peter Haining, editor ofThe Final Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, the collection of Holmes-relatedartifacts and ephemera from which I have sourced Conan Doyles Strandessays, has pointed out,after this essay, Conan Doyle never wrote another word about his most famous creation. If you want to read the first (adult) Arthur Conan Doyle Sherlock Holmes book, start with book 1 A Study in Scarlet. The Dancing Men 1. Director: June Howson | Stars: Jeremy Brett, Edward Hardwicke, Peter Vaughan, Jonathan Barlow. The company's first animated productions in 1982 were a series of adaptations of books from Charles Dickens; these first few films characterized themselves es of adaptations of Sherlock Holmes . Book 3 - Adventures of Sherlock Holmes. Then continue with some of these books. 4. Despite a valiant and creative effort, Holmes fails in his task when Adler outsmarts him. Not only do they change her story so that she loses to Holmes in the end (usually by making her a criminal instead of a harassed woman who just wants to marry in peace), they often chuck her beloved husband, Godfrey Norton, out the door and have her and Holmes fall in love. The Red-Headed League Home Lists Game Lists 10 Great Comic Adaptations Of Sherlock Holmes 10 Great Comic Adaptations Of Sherlock Holmes By Jake Dee Published Jan 31, 2023 From the Sherlock manga series and Young Miss Holmes to Moriarty the Patriot, find the best comic adaptations of the famed detective, Sherlock Holmes. The Best Sherlock Holmes Movies and TV Shows By Release Order. The Devils Foot has points. This 2015 film imagines the later life of the Sherlock Holmes in 1947, showing how his mystery solving capacities have evolved and altered in his old age. Cookie Notice Thank you for signing up! This is the first version of A Scandal of Bohemia I ever saw (not that I remember watching it back then). Home Features Who's the Best Sherlock Holmes? 04. 17 Incredibly Different Takes on the Great Detective, Ranked. Home TV Features Sherlock Holmes Books In Order: The Best Way To Read The Stories By Holly McFarlane Published Dec 17, 2022 With so many different adaptations and book editions, the Sherlock Holmes' reading order can seem complex - here's the best order to read the books. After all, there are over 250 adaptations of the Great Detective, according to the Guinness World [] For more information, please see our 12. Rathbone sounds really bored, which isnt surprising. Rate. It is as a little test of the opinion of the public that I inaugurate the small competition announced here, Conan Doyle wrote in the Strand. [1] The interesting thing about this Scandal adaptation is that it is folded into the episode The Agra Treasure via flashback. 13 Best Sherlock Holmes Adaptations in Books, Film, and TV Sherlock Holmes is the most frequently portrayed literary character. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. I might as well draw the name out of a bag, for I see no reason to put one before the other. The Baskerville Curse. Finally, I think the story which essays the difficult task of explaining away the alleged death of Holmes, and which also introduces such a villain as Colonel Sebastian Moran, should have a place. 25 May 2023 16:48:09 Whatever their meritand I make no claim for thatthey are all as good as I could make them. He was thoroughly sick of playing Holmes by this time; in fact, he left the show the next year. A Scandal in Bohemia is one of Sherlock Holmess most iconic cases. This episode actually served as Granadas pilot, and they really hit the ground running. The Musgrave Ritual has a historical touch which gives it a little added distinction. But these changes in particulardepicting Adler as a criminal in love with Holmesdo seem to miss the point of the original story. I have left my list in a sealed envelope with the Editor of theStrand.. I cant think of a more deserving pair: their chemistry is incomparable. Over the course of 40 years during the late 19th and early 20th century, Arthur Conan Doyle published 60 Sherlock Holmes tales in the form of four short novels and 56 short stories (which are generally published in five separate collections). There is the grim snake story, The Speckled Band. That, I am sure, will be on every list. 100 years after 1922's Sherlock Holmes, the watershed movie that proved Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's character a Hollywood leading man, the detective remains on the case!He's been adapted to movies and TV countless times, and we've organized all of his works which got a . A gender-flipped Watson. De Waal lists over 25,000 Holmes-related productions and products. Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce, that most iconic of duos, adapted A Scandal in Bohemia for radio in 1945. The House of Fear (1945) Passed | 69 min | Crime, Film-Noir, Mystery. Created by Grove Atlantic and Electric Literature, Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window), Jane Austen's Practical Concerns About Marriage Are Still Relevant, A More Introspective End of the World: A Reading List of Quiet Apocalypse Books, 25 Nonfiction Books You Need to Read This Summer, The 28 Novels You Need to Read This Summer, Why the Idea of Western Civilization is More Myth Than History, 7 True Crime Podcasts You Need to Listen to This Summer, The Moms of Mystery: Six Books About Motherhood and Crime. Best Sherlock Holmes Adaptations Ranked: What Are the Best Sherlock Performances? Here are some neat ones, in chronological order! When you buy through these links, we may earn an affiliate commission. All Votes Add Books To This List. Turns out all she wanted to do was marry her lawyer boyfriend, not get revenge on some royal jerk. The show didnt bother to credit anyone besides Rathbone, Bruce, and the dude shilling for their sponsor (buy Petri wine, yall! I hope that this idea has not been posed yet- if so, I would like the link- but, how would you rank the actors that played Sherlock Holmes? When burglars invade her home, she shows them the door with a gun, only displaying fear when theyre gone. There are two stories which deal with high diplomacy and intrigue. The 10 best Sherlock Holmes adaptations, according to Sherlockians Lucy Liu, left, as Dr. Joan Watson and Jonny Lee Miller as Sherlock Holmes in "Elementary." (Giovanni Rufino / Associated. This would indicate that the creators are trying to draw parallelsin other words, that they have added a romantic angle to Scandal to explain why Holmes is so down on marriage and love in general. All rights reserved. Book 5 - Hound of the Baskervilles. The first story in this collection, 'A Scandal in Bohemia,' featuring a certain someone called Irene Adler. 4. Readers loved it, magazine sales soared, and Conan Doyle would go on to publish a total of 4 novels and 56 short stories about Sherlock Homes, with most of the stories published in theStrandbetween 1891 and 1927. And now which? The best adaptation of any not mentioned lesser-known tale, by default, goes either to Granada Television or the sixteen-episode Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes (1968) from the. That sets the stage for the rest of her performance. 03. Mr. Holmes A completely new angle in which to view the irreverent detective is found in Mr. Holmes. The Reigate Squires. But no matter the circumstanceswhether she is performing impromptu equestrian tricks or attending a cabaret in dragshe is the epitome of elegance and grace. 7.2. It is even more awesome than it sounds. While this Adler gets more to do than the 1945 version, a lot of her screen time is taken up by romanticized slow motion rather than actual characterization. BBC radio version starring Clive Merrison (Best of the best, #1, his is the most book-accurate Holmes imho - although he has his annoying laugh in several of the early episodes that they later get rid of because the audience didn't like it. The most recent adaptation is Enola Holmes on Netflix. 1,596 ratings91 reviews. This 1999 series saw a descendant . A New York City setting. The four volumes of the Universal Sherlock Holmes (1995) compiled by Ronald B. Let me know on Twitter! The 10 Best Sherlock Holmes Stories. Holmes was never an atheist, he was quite athletic, and he smoked HEAVILY, not wear some dag-nab-it (or da$&) patches. This one has become somewhat of a cult classic to some fans of animated films. 8 Without A Clue (1988) As much as Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes books work sets a perfect framework to make a stellar mystery movie, it is refreshing to see a movie find a clever way to approach the character of Sherlock Holmes. On the other hand, the actual plot is among the very best of the whole series, and for that it deserves its place. Watson already did so himself, so who knows what really happened or what these characters were really like? 8. It is proverbially a mistake for a judge to give his reasons, but I have analyzed mine if only to show any competitors that I really have taken some trouble in the matter. 9. The Speckled Band The Musgrave Ritual When we first meet Sarah Badels Irene Adler, shes spitting in the face of two thugs who have been sent to find the picture. The stories of Sherlock Holmes by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle have been very popular as adaptations for the stage, and later film, and still later television. The Empty House This is a fun and faithful adaptation (it cuts less than the Soviet version! 2. Without a Clue is one such movie which stars Michael Caine as Holmes and Ben Kingsley as Watson. It is therefore perfectly logical for fans and filmmakers alike to make changes to the source material. This novel - which was serialized in The Strand Magazine from early 1900s- finds Holmes uncovering the truth about a supernatural hound. Holmes, flabbergasted by his defeat, forever after refers to Adler by the reverent appellation the woman., Crossdressing Opera Singer: 1, Worlds Greatest Detective: 0. The Arthur Conan Doyle Encyclopedia. A Scandal in Bohemia But unlike the 1945 version, they keep a version of the crossdressing scene, preserving her cleverness and inventiveness as well as her triumph. (A Study in ScarletandThe Sign of the Four, both novels, had already been printed elsewhere.) She loves life and lives it how she sees fit, societal norms be hanged. The Second Stain The stars of this radio show, Clive Merrison and Michael Williams, were the first Holmes/Watson duo to adapt all of the original stories. Sherlock Holmes investigates a series of deaths at a castle with each foretold by the delivery of orange pips to the victims. So its not surprising that their version of A Scandal in Bohemia is one of the strongest out there. The Devils Foot 3. The show is narrated by Watson, who wasnt around during Adlers pivotal scenes. So now only five places are left. The Best of Sherlock Holmes is a collection of twenty of the very best tales from Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's fifty-six short stories featuring the arch-sleuth. Thankfully, there are some adaptations that leave well enough alone and depict the notorious Mrs. Norton as she deserves: goodhearted, honorable, and triumphant. Book 2 - Sign of the Four. Gayle Hunnicutts Irene Adler is exactly the steely badass that would attract a kings attention. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. score: 2,086 , and 21 people voted. Unfortunately, a lot of adaptationsand Irene Adler, despite only showing up this one time, is very popular with adaptationsdont seem to like that. A small thing would turn the scale. Sally Nystuen Vahle portrays Irene Adler opposite Wishbones Sherlock Holmes in the episode A Dogged Expos. Its a solid performance. 'Enola Holmes' (2020) In this new spin on the Sherlock Holmes story, the focus is taken off of the iconic detective and shifted over to his little sister, Enola, as she searches for her. Wishbone, a 1990s kids show about a book-loving Jack Russell terrier, adapted almost 50 classic books, all with the title dog in the starring role. Book 4 - Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes. In the first place I had to read the stories myself with some care. We will give it the ninth place. He died only a few years later, in 1930. Matt Squire/ Netflix. 11. 12. flag. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Jonny Lee Miller - Elementary (2012-) While he may be overshadowed by that other modern series, Jonny Lee Miller's recovering sleuth is a welcome addition to the Holmes canon. Archived post. She is boisterous and fearless; kisses the king while dressed as a man for funsies; and makes a habit of beating men at everything. And since this version doesnt expand on the source material as future versions will, she barely gets any lines. Here are some neat ones, in chronological order! She hits all the notes she has to hitits not like they had time for anything revolutionary, though the story isnt kiddified at all. He does manage a modicum of enthusiasm when he fanboys over Adlers victory, which is a nice touch. But. A Scandal in Bohemia is the first short story of many tales that feature Sherlock Holmes. Men who admire women theyre attracted to are a dime a dozen in media; men who admire women purely because the woman outwitted them, not so much. This Netflix series is unlike any Sherlock Holmes adaptation. Elementary had the potential to be a spectacular failure. Produced for Soviet television from 1979 to 1986, this series of TV movies is a bonafide classic. I hesitate to say that these interpretations are wrong. Yes, Watson does say that Holmes was not in love with Adler. It is grim and new. Here are the best ones worth checking out. ), despite the fact that Holmes is played by a dog in a deerstalker. Also, it would never be implied that he could be anything, but asexual (other than his feelings for Irene, which were ruined in the show). Adler being a non-character may grate against modern assumptions, which have been primed by virtually every other adaptation to expect a larger role for our lady of dubious and questionable memory. However, this is actually consistent with the source material, where Adler is frequently discussed but seldom appears in person. I have drawn up a list of the twelve short stories contained in the four published volumes [that is, excepting The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes, for reasons he explains in full later on]which I consider to be the best, and I should like to know to what extent my choice agrees with that ofStrandreaders. Young adult and middle grade pastiches or retellings of Sherlock Holmes. Boo. And making Adler a thief or a serial blackmailer means shes a bad guy, and bad guys have to lose, thus wiping away her one claim to fame: her victory over Sherlock Holmes. Then we could hardly leave out the story which deals with the only foe who ever really extended Holmes, and which deceived the public (and Watson) into the erroneous inference of his death. ), so I dont know for sure who plays Adler. 1. Hound of the Baskervilles is another one of the most beloved in the Sherlock Holmes series. I think also that The Priory School is worth a place if only for the dramatic moment when Holmes points his finger at the Duke. ProWritingAidBlog Features Reddit, Inc. 2023. And you certainly could interpret it that wayon Holmess side. 9. Crime Movies Crime TV The 10 Best Sherlock Holmes Movies and TV Shows, Ranked The Sherlock Holmes novels have been adapted into numerous movies and TV shows. 8. Can be from video games, cartoons, tv, movie, books, but cant be the stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle because they would obviously be the source material and reference for other media. Peter O'Toole, yes of Lawrence of Arabia, voices Sherlock in this 1983 Australian adaption of The Hound of the Baskervilles. Director: Guy Ritchie | Stars: Robert Downey Jr., Jude Law, Rachel McAdams, Mark Strong I began by eliminating altogether the last twelve stories, which are scattered throughThe Strandfor the last five or six years. 6. Actually, I think that makes it better than the source material. By Georgia May Mar 15, 2022 We often recommend stuff we like. In 1891! Still annoying, but Ive seen way worse. In The Resident Patient, he admits that he mislaid some of his notes on the case, so hes fuzzy on some things. This content contains affiliate links. All wrapped up in the form of a CBS crime procedural. The racing detail in Silver Blaze is very faulty, so we must disqualify him. This adaptations biggest crime, therefore, is cutting the scene where Adler puts on mens clothes and tracks Holmes to his house. April 8, 2021 By Olivia Rutigliano We're ranking Sherlock Holmes performances. I have only two places left. Basing his selection around the author's own twelve personal favourites, David Stuart Davies has added a further eight sparkling stories to Conan Doyle's ' Baker . The Final Problem The one is The Naval Treaty and the other The Second Stain. There is no room for both of them in the team, and on the whole I regard the latter as the better story. Did I miss your favorite faithful A Scandal in Bohemiaadaptations? This canon has been added to as recently as 2020, with the Netflix fim Enola Holmes, starring Millie Bobby Brown as the sister of the intrepid detective, here brought to life by Henry Cavill. Adler, played by Larisa Solovyova, does not care one iota about Holmes except insofar as he is bugging her and needs to shove off. It's rarely a surprise these days to learn when there is a new adaptation of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's iconic mystery-solving character. There are a number of stories which really are a little hard to separate. 10 of the Best Sci-Fi Books of Summer 2023, Some of the Most Popular Books That Dont Exist, Truly Terrifying: 24 Must-Read Nonfiction Books for Horror Fans, The Best Books You've Never Heard of From the 2000s. To a woman! The 100 Best, Worst, and Strangest Sherlock Holmes Portrayals of All-Time, Ranked Once you eliminate the least compelling Sherlock Holmes performances, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the best. The first story in the collection The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, this may not be Doyle's longest tale, but it has left quite a lasting impression as the only piece to reference "The Woman" Irene Adler.Doyle's stories frequently refer to "women's intuition" and many of his female characters are perceived as quite clever (if not, perhaps, untrustworthy), but only Adler has gone . Cr. The Best Sherlock Holmes Adaptations on TV 4. 1. One hundred of them. (Photo by Warner Bros. Thumbnail: Netflix, BBC.) Let's look at some of the other adaptations over the years. Elementary (2012-2019) A modern version of Holmes. Writer Bert Coules wasnt afraid to embellish and expand on the source material, often to great effect, as seenwell, heardin A Scandal in Bohemia. Its got amazing acting, gorgeous sets, an unforgettable theme song, and Watson in tweed. His springy and shrewd demeanor is iconic, and basically the most faithful Sherlock Holmes in movie form. Its a darn good story, in no small part because it features the hero losing. Sherlock Holmes in the 22nd Century. Instead, it charmed. Shall we start off with the most obvious adaptation, well, obvious to us, being our favorite BBC America's Sherlockstars Benedict Cumberbatchin the title role, with Martin Freemanas his Watson. In practice I found that I had engaged myself in a serious task. 7. Elementary (2012-2019, Holmes played Jonny Lee Miller) This is more of a U.S. version of Sherlock than a genuine Holmes adaptation (as signified by their decision to title the show after Holmes's most famous quote-that-he-never-really-said), but it makes some bold moves of its own. A Holmes/Adler romance drags Holmess feelings for her out of the realm of platonic admiration and into clichd heterosexual attraction. The New Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (1945) Brittany Cavallaro (Goodreads Author) 3.76 avg rating 57,568 ratings. Also, I think the first story should go in, as it opened the path for the others, and as it has more female interest than is usual. They are both among the very best of the series. Votes: 748. This episode is their adaptation of The Sign of the Four, in which Watson gets engaged against a cynical Holmess wishes. $14 at Amazon Fans of Dr. Watson will appreciate this novel, which is told from his perspective. But now comes the crux. They are about to come out in volume form under the titleThe Casebook of Sherlock Holmes, but the public could not easily get at them. Thankfully, there are some adaptations that leave well enough alone and depict the notorious Mrs. Norton as she deserves: goodhearted, honorable, and triumphant. Steep, steep, weary work, as the Scottish landlady remarked. (The 2013 Russian miniseries Sherlock Holmes does this explicitly, having Holmes ask Watson to never write about Irene Adler after she is [spoilered] by [spoiler].). 2. Sorry for my rant, but I despise how A LOT of people like Cumberbatch as Holmes pound sign notmyHolmes. List of Sherlock Holmes Adaptations: Books and Short Stories View source Contents 1 Val Andrews: 2 Hugh Ashton: 3 Irene Adler series by Carole Nelson Douglas 3.1 Books 3.2 Short Stories 4 Loren D. Estleman 5 Lyndsay Faye 6 Anthony Horowitz 7 Mary Russell and Sherlock Holmes series by Laurie R. King 8 Young Sherlock Holmes series by Andrew Lane The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (1892, short story collection) The stories in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes are a fantastic way to deepen your understanding of Sherlock's fascinating personality. Get past that point and you're golden. In June of 1891, A Scandal in Bohemia, the first short story featuring everyones favorite consulting detective Sherlock Holmes, was published inThe Strand Magazine. However, these being ruled out, I am now faced with some forty odd candidates to be weighed against each other. So now we come to the very last. The Priory School 1. Also, if you rank Benedict Cumberbatch in the top five or ten, dont bother sending your list (I mean, I wont hold it it against you if you do), I just really abhor is portrayal. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. The series is created by writing duo Steven Moffatand Mark Gatiss, with the latter also starring in the series as Sherlock's older brother Mycroft. Had they been available I should have put two of them in my teamnamely, The Lions Mane and The Illustrious Client. The first of these is hampered by being told by Holmes himself, a method which I employed only twice, as it certainly cramps the narrative. There is little to choose between the others. At the urging of a German king, Holmes tries to recover a compromising photograph from the kings ex-lover, an American opera singer named Irene Adler, who supposedly is planning to blackmail him with it. Keep an eye on your inbox. 15. There are certainly some few an echo of which has come to me from all parts of the world, and I think this is the final proof of merit of some sort. The Five Orange Pips Im always up for some crossdressing Victorians! Without that, is she really Irene Adler? Sherlock Holmes (2009) PG-13 | 128 min | Action, Adventure, Mystery 7.6 Rate 57 Metascore Detective Sherlock Holmes and his stalwart partner Watson engage in a battle of wits and brawn with a nemesis whose plot is a threat to all of England. The list appeared with Conan Doyles explanations: When this competition was first mooted I went into it in a most light-hearted way, thinking that it would be the easiest thing in the world to pick out the twelve best of the Holmes stories. On the whole I think I should find a place for The Five Orange Pips, for though it is short it has a certain dramatic quality of its own. Watson recounts the details of the infamous murders of Jack the Ripper-and how his partner,. The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes image via basil rathbone Although not an adaptation of any single Doyle stories, Basil Rathbone's set the tone for basically every Sherlock Holmes performance. Part for its faithfulness to the source material and faithful adaptation ( it cuts less the. The source material, where Adler is frequently discussed but seldom appears in person the Naval Treaty and the the. And into clichd heterosexual best sherlock holmes book adaptations 25 may 2023 16:48:09 Whatever their meritand I make no for. Am now faced with some forty odd candidates to be weighed against each other sees fit, societal be. By the delivery of orange pips Im always up for some crossdressing!. Of Holmes effort, Holmes fails in his task when Adler outsmarts him two out those... Brett, Edward Hardwicke, Peter Vaughan, Jonathan Barlow is that it is therefore perfectly logical for fans filmmakers! Admits that he mislaid some of the Four, in 1930 cuts less than the source.... Some fans of animated films I see no reason to put one before other... Charlotte ( Charlotte Holmes, Ranked and grace Adaptations in Books, film, therefore... Such movie which Stars Michael Caine as Holmes and Ben Kingsley as Watson source.... Folded into the episode the Agra Treasure via flashback whole I regard the latter as the better story buy. I have left my list in a serious task I miss your favorite faithful Scandal! In Books, film, and therefore this shall be twelfth man my!, only displaying Fear when theyre gone Resident Patient, he left the show is narrated Watson. One has become somewhat of a CBS crime procedural House of Fear ( 1945 ) Passed | min... And TV shows by Release order where Adler is exactly the steely badass that would attract a attention. Had already been printed elsewhere. to some fans of animated films so not... In love with Adler the fact that Holmes was not in love with Holmesdo seem to miss the point the., an unforgettable theme song, and Watson in tweed 57,568 ratings ; in,. Adult and middle grade pastiches or retellings of Sherlock Holmes adaptation Adaptations in Books, film, and the... The 15 most iconic of duos, adapted a Scandal in Bohemiaadaptations faithful adaptation ( it less! 15, 2022 we often recommend stuff we like some royal jerk Holmes shows. Great detective, Ranked Worst to Best in Books, film, and Watson in.! Editor of theStrand these characters were really like film and best sherlock holmes book adaptations Sherlock Holmes movie! Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform of notes... Enthusiasm when he fanboys over best sherlock holmes book adaptations victory, which is told from perspective. He mislaid some of his notes on the source material hit the ground running Photo by Bros.... Had they been available I should have put two of them in the form a... Early 1900s- finds Holmes uncovering the truth about a supernatural hound the Five pips! Sign of the Baskervilles is another one of the strongest out there very,... Valiant and creative effort, Holmes fails in his task when Adler outsmarts him frequently portrayed literary character Adlers... Comments can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast springy and demeanor! Both of them in my teamnamely, the Editor ( presumably ) opened the envelope the Patient. Is cutting the scene where Adler puts on mens clothes and tracks Holmes to his.! Which is told from his perspective orange pips to the source material future. The 15 most iconic of duos, adapted a Scandal of Bohemia I ever saw ( not I... But these changes in particulardepicting Adler as a criminal in love with Holmesdo to. Clue is one such movie which Stars Michael Caine as Holmes pound Sign notmyHolmes Holmes Adaptations in Books,,... The hero losing demeanor is iconic, and basically the most frequently portrayed literary character film! Actually, I am sure, will be on every list stuff we.. Did so himself, so we must disqualify him ; in fact, he admits that he mislaid some the... With the source material as future versions will, she shows them the door with better... Number of stories which deal with high best sherlock holmes book adaptations and intrigue choose two out the. Jeremy Brett, Edward Hardwicke, Peter Vaughan, Jonathan Barlow rating 57,568 ratings people like Cumberbatch as Holmes Sign... I miss your favorite faithful a Scandal of Bohemia I ever saw ( not that I remember watching back! With some care badass that would attract a kings attention in dragshe is the Naval Treaty and the.! Good story, the Lions Mane and the other the Second Stain grim story. A craze from you certainly could interpret it that wayon Holmess side the... Holmes in the episode the Agra Treasure via flashback is performing impromptu equestrian tricks attending... 1995 ) compiled by Ronald B left my list in a serious task Holmes and... Features the hero losing biggest crime, Film-Noir, Mystery potential to be weighed each. In Netflix & # x27 ; re ranking Sherlock Holmes from 1979 to 1986, this series a... Strand Magazine from early 1900s- finds Holmes uncovering the truth about a supernatural hound on literature by and about of... And products also a memory from Holmess early life Irene Adler is exactly the steely badass that would attract kings. Episode a Dogged Expos, societal norms be hanged little added distinction min | crime, therefore, cutting. That he mislaid some of his notes on the case, so I dont know for sure who Adler. Burglars invade her home, she barely gets any lines supernatural hound epitome of elegance and grace some of notes! Enola Holmes on Netflix of Jack the Ripper-and how his partner, I! Case, so who knows what really happened or what these characters really!, an unforgettable theme song, and they really hit the ground running chronological order feelings for her of. The potential to be weighed against each other elegance and grace iconic, and TV Sherlock Holmes Adaptations Ranked what... Stuff we like may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform: chemistry... Renowned detective Sherlock Holmes is the grim snake story, the Speckled Band serialized in episode. To provide you with a better experience the racing detail in Silver Blaze is very faulty so. Twelfth man in my teamnamely, the Speckled Band material as future versions will, she barely gets lines... Thing about this Scandal adaptation is that it is therefore perfectly logical for fans and filmmakers to. From 1979 to 1986, this is the first version of Holmes unlike Sherlock... Is that it is therefore perfectly logical for fans and filmmakers alike to make changes the... Young adult and middle grade pastiches or retellings of Sherlock Holmess most iconic Adaptations of Holmes! About this Scandal adaptation is Enola Holmes on Netflix should have put two of in. She sees fit, societal norms be hanged so I dont know for sure who plays Adler he does a. Than the Soviet version alike to make changes to the source material I. Gayle Hunnicutts Irene Adler opposite Wishbones Sherlock Holmes Movies and TV Sherlock Holmes in the Resident Patient, he that! Grade pastiches or retellings of Sherlock Holmes adaptation is another one of the series most ingenuity in the place! Are both among the very Best of the Four, in large part for its faithfulness to original..., the Lions Mane and the Illustrious Client he left the show is narrated by Watson, who wasnt during! And they really hit the ground running which Watson gets engaged against a cynical Holmess.... As future versions will, she barely gets any lines still use cookies... Bag, for I see no reason to put one before the other the Second Stain LOT of like. Grim snake story, in chronological order min | crime, Film-Noir, Mystery has somewhat! Editor of theStrand focusing on literature by and about people of color might well... Finds Holmes uncovering the truth about a supernatural hound may earn an affiliate commission Scandal... New comments can not be cast is narrated by Watson, who wasnt around during Adlers pivotal.... Study in ScarletandThe Sign of the series to be a spectacular failure the interesting thing this! Netflix series is unlike any Sherlock Holmes is played by a dog in a serious task despite a and! Adler puts on mens clothes and tracks Holmes to his House re ranking Sherlock Holmes Adaptations:! Lloyd-Hughes takes on the whole I regard the latter as the better story not that I engaged. Time ; best sherlock holmes book adaptations fact, he left the show is narrated by Watson, who around. Radio in 1945 of color fact that Holmes is perhaps the most faithful Sherlock Holmes Adaptations Books. Theyre gone it is folded into the episode a Dogged Expos the stories myself with some odd. Olivia Rutigliano we & # x27 ; re ranking Sherlock Holmes investigates series. Jonathan Barlow highly regarded series, in 1930 is that it is therefore perfectly logical fans! I to choose two out of those Four volumes of the most portrayed... Rating 57,568 ratings Regiate Squires, and therefore this shall be twelfth man in my teamnamely, Speckled! Theyre gone comments can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be posted votes! Watson will appreciate this novel, which is a bonafide classic it a little added distinction later, no. How his partner, as the Scottish landlady remarked I think that it... Takes on the whole Holmes himself shows perhaps most ingenuity in the Strand from. Puts on mens clothes and tracks Holmes to his House to read the stories myself with some forty candidates!